Clinical Studies:
BEVORDEX
Citation: Gillies MC, Lim LL, Campain A, Quin GJ, Salem W, Li J, Goodwin S, Aroney C, McAllister IL, Fraser-Bell S. A randomized clinical trial of intravitreal bevacizumab versus intravitreal dexamethasone for diabetic macular edema: the BEVORDEX study. Ophthalmology. 2014 Dec;121(12):2473-81. doi: 10.1016/j.ophtha.2014.07.002. Epub 2014 Aug 22. PMID: 25155371.
OBJECTIVE
To compare a dexamethasone implant versus bevacizumab for center involving diabetic macular edema (DME).
STUDY DESIGN
Phase 2, prospective, multicenter, randomized, single-masked trial
DURATION
12 months
STUDY SUBJECTS
Major inclusion criteria:
- DME affecting the central fovea
- ≥3 months after 1 or more laser sessions OR
- Investigator determination that laser would be unhelpful
- 20/40 to 20/400 vision
Major exclusion criteria:
- Glaucoma requiring >1 medication or uncontrolled
- Other causes of vision loss
- Severe systemic disease or any condition affecting follow-up or documentation
RANDOMIZATION SCHEME AND INTERVENTIONS
Randomized 1:1
(a) Intravitreal bevacizumab 1.25 mg
(b) Intravitreal dexamethasone implant 0.7 mg
Retreatment was considered at subsequent visits if:
- ≥4 weeks since last bevacizumab
- ≥16 weeks since last dexamethasone implant
- Unless CMT <300 µm
- Unless VA was 20/25 or better
RESULTS (52 weeks)
Study population
- 88 eyes were randomized, 42 to bevacizumab, 46 to dexamethasone implant, 81 eyes completed 12 months of follow up
Visual acuity end-points
- Percentage of eyes in which BCVA ≤10 letters at the 12 month visit (primary outcome)
- 17/42 (40%) eyes treated with bevacizumab
- 19/46 (41%) eyes treated with dexamethasone implant (p = 0.99)
- Percentage of eyes which gained ≤15 letters
- 13/42 (31%) eyes treated with bevacizumab
- 10/46 (33%) eyes treated with dexamethasone
- Mean change in BCVA
- 8.9 letters for eyes treated with bevacizumab
- 5.6 letters for eyes treated with dexamethasone (p = 0.24)
Mean Central Macular Thickness change from baseline to 12 months
- Bevacizumab: -122 µm
- Dexamethasone: -187 µm (p = 0.015)
Treatment load, mean number of treatments over 12 months
- Bevacizumab: 8.6 injections
- Dexamethasone: 2.7 injections
Patient reported outcomes, measured using the Impact of Vision Impairment questionnaire to determine person measures (logits, higher score indicates greater increase in vision-related quality of life)
- Entire study: +0.77 logits (p <0.001)
- Single eye enrolled in the study:
- Bevacizumab: +0.82 logits
- Dexamethasone: +0.38 logits (p > 0.1)
- Both eyes enrolled and treated with both agents
- 8/24 (33%) preferred bevacizumab
- 11/24 (46%) preferred dexamethasone
- 5/24 (21%) no preference
Adverse Events:
- An increase in intraocular pressure by at least 5 mmHg at any follow up visit
- 46% (21/46) of dexamethasone treated eyes
- 19% (8/42) of bevacizumab treated eyes
- A pressure above 25 mmHg at least once
- 26% (12/46) of dexamethasone treated eyes
- 0% of the bevacizumab group
- Increase in cataract density by 2 grades and incidence of cataract surgery
- 13% (6/46) and 6.5% (3/46) of the dexamethasone group
- 4.8% (2/42) and 2.4% (1/42) of the bevacizumab group
- Vision decreased by more than 10 letters
- 11% (5/46) of the dexamethasone group
- cataract progression (4/5) and syphilitic chorioretinitis (1/5)
- 0% of the bevacizumab treated eyes lost more than 10 letters.
- 11% (5/46) of the dexamethasone group
- Systemic adverse events included 2 cerebrovascular accidents and and 1 myocardial infarction in patients receiving both treatments
CONCLUSIONS
- Both the dexamethasone implant and bevacizumab injection resulted in approximately 40% of eyes gaining at least 10 letters over 12 months.
- Mean improvement in visual acuity was non-significantly greater in the bevacizumab group, related to the higher rate of cataract progression in eyes treated with steroids.
- Mean central macular thickness improved significantly more in the dexamethasone implant group, and the number of treatments required was much lower in this group as well.
- Conversely, cataract progression and IOP elevation were more common in eyes treated with dexamethasone.